Robert Heinlein, Virginia Heinlein, Snowy Heinlein Pay Forward the legacy of Robert A. Heinlein --Contribute to The Heinlein Society today! Join the Heinlein Society in paying forward the legacy of Robert A. Heinlein and Virginia Heinlein. Return Home to the Heinlein Society Heinlein Society Recent Updates Go To Centennial Reader


Robert Heinlein

Ginny Heinlein


RAH And Me

Join Us

Pay Annual Dues






Blood Drives


Pirates' Booty

на русском


Contact Us


Heinlein Prize

Readers Group






Writing Contest


Heinlein Reader's Discussion Group

Saturday Sept 15, 2001 5:00 P.M. EDT

Pioneering in Heinlein - The Final Frontier

Click Here to Return to Index

Return To Index

You have just entered room "Heinlein Readers Group chat."

maikoshT has entered the room.

geeairmoe2 has entered the room.

DavidWrightSr: Hi Will. Nobody here yet, but me and my alter ego.

DavidWrightSr: Don't know if we will have many tonight. Jane is going to be late.

geeairmoe2: I'd noticed Jane's post that she would be late and might need someone to open things up.

geeairmoe2: I'v got a few internet-related tasks to clean up. I'll check back.

DavidWrightSr: Ok. I'm working on something too.

AGplusone has entered the room.

AGplusone: Hi, Will, David.

DavidWrightSr: Hi David.

AGplusone: crummy week, eh?

DavidWrightSr: Just told Ginny and Will that I have to be AFK for a while.

DavidWrightSr: I have to take my wife to get something to eat.

geeairmoe2: Hello.

AGplusone: Enjoy it.

DavidWrightSr: I'll leave both of my copies running to get the log. Yes a very crummy week.

DavidWrightSr: Understatement of the century.

DavidWrightSr: See you later

AGplusone: see ya!

AGplusone: The century's young.

geeairmoe2: Just finishing up some other internet tasks, so if I don't answer, don't be alarmed.

AGplusone: I won't ... sipping my wake-up tea.

geeairmoe2: I annoyed some people on Sff.Net's group about the bombing.

AGplusone: who?

SAcademy has entered the room.

AGplusone: Hi, Ginny!

geeairmoe2: Hello, m'am.

SAcademy: Good evening everyone. David W. had to take his wife out to dinner.

ddavitt has entered the room.

ddavitt: Hello everyone.

AGplusone: Hi, Jane.

geeairmoe2: Hi, Jane.

SAcademy: Hi, Jane.

ddavitt: I am here until L wakes up and demands food; David is at work.

ddavitt: Are you feeling better David S?

SAcademy: I willlhave to leave soon, have a very sore throat.

ddavitt: Sorry to hear that Ginny

AGplusone: better when I'm awake. How's your flu, Ginny ... just what I was about to ask

geeairmoe2: Sorry to hear that. Gargle salty water.

ddavitt: Hot whisky toddy with lots of honey

SAcademy: That's a thought! Haven't tried that yet.

ddavitt: It tastes nicer than salt water too :-)

geeairmoe2: It is nasty, but it always works for me.

ddavitt: I have heard that too Will

AGplusone: The whisky tastes better too.

geeairmoe2: As a non-drinker I can't comment on the other.

AGplusone: saltwater tastes yucky

ddavitt: It's medicinal Will

AGplusone: clears the sinuses

geeairmoe2: Not saltwater, salty water. A teaspoon or two in warm water.

ddavitt: Did you all get chance to read the log from Thursday?

AGplusone: Yes

ddavitt: Good.

geeairmoe2: Nope.

ddavitt: bad:-)

WJaKe has entered the room.

AGplusone: 'change' doesn't mean we read it, however. Hi, Jake

AGplusone: chance

geeairmoe2: Been researching how the bombing fits into Armegeddon in Revelations.

ddavitt: Never mind; if we go over same ground it doesn't matter. Hi there

DenvToday has entered the room.

AGplusone: Hi, Ron

ddavitt: Hi again Denv

DenvToday: Greetings everybody!

DenvToday: Hello :-)

AGplusone: Have to read Steve's account in Job:ACOJ

AGplusone: ;-)

ddavitt: Is everyone ready to start the chat?

AGplusone: I was always intrigued when Alec meets up with them in Heaven and Steve gives that little hint of an a

AGplusone: account

DJedPar has entered the room.

AGplusone: Hi, Denis

ddavitt: Hi Denis

DenvToday: Hi Denis

DJedPar: Hi David, Hi Everybody

ddavitt: Maybe we'll wait a bit, see if any more people drop in...

ddavitt: Or then again maybe we won't

ddavitt: We were discussing colonisation on Thursday

ddavitt: And whetehr any of us coddled sissies could hack it any more

fgherman has entered the room.

ddavitt: Can we do without all the tech and comforts, not just for a holiday but for ever?

AGplusone: Hi Felicia

fgherman: Helllo all

ddavitt: Hi Felicia

SAcademy: Good evening Felicia.

DenvToday: Good afternoon Felicia

ddavitt: Or can we colonise now and expect to get the comfort level back up quite fast?

geeairmoe2: Humans are adaptable. No matter how high or low that comfort level is, humans adapt.

AGplusone: food rationing, no new 'putors every year, have to make do with '41 model Fords, gosh ...

ddavitt: Could you get used to it you think?

geeairmoe2: Wheter I'd voluntarily give them up is one question. If its forced on me, I adapt.

ddavitt: I'm not sure I could

AGplusone: gas rationing

DenvToday: David, you just described Cuba.

fgherman: I sure I'd be able to adapt

AGplusone: I just described 1942-45

geeairmoe2: When its adapt or perish, you'll find yourself capable of extraordinary feats.

fgherman: Just think how luxurious our life looks to someone from just 100 years ago

ddavitt: true..

AGplusone: [or 39-45, in Britain]

AGplusone: Do you think the cubanos under Castro are pioneering spirit tough, Ron?

ddavitt: brb

DenvToday: I think they must be hardy just to make it from day to day. So in a sense, perhaps. But having the..

fgherman: I think the Cuban people are capable of extraordinary accomplishments, just like most other humans

AGplusone: Adaptable, resolute, patriotic

DenvToday: ...pioneering spirit suggest some free will in the mater.

AGplusone: agreed

DenvToday: Most Cubans would get out if they could.

AGplusone: altho those driven from a society can be pioneers. the pilgrims were driven out

DenvToday: Good point. But still, they had a choice of places to go.

fgherman: They don't have alot of choice in the matter, though

DenvToday: Cubans have no choice.

AGplusone: many of those who left the south, ca. 1865, left because they had 'nothing' left

AGplusone: or felt that way

geeairmoe2: "Pioneering Spirit" shows a mental requirement is needed. Ya got to WANT it.

fgherman: I've lost track of how many countries the Jews have been kicked out of.

AGplusone: Yes.

AGplusone: M y grandparents got tired of pogroms

AGplusone: The Irish greatgrandparents got tired of starving.

geeairmoe2: In 'normal' society you can cruise along whether you want it or not.

DenvToday: Interesting note: More Jews were summarily expelled from Arab countries after the founding of...

AGplusone: The Italian grandfather left because there waa a feud back home that would have

AGplusone: killed him had he returned.

DenvToday: ...Israel than there were Arabs who lost their homes in the new state of Israel.

DenvToday: All all Arabs were invited to stay in Israel.

fgherman: And the Arabs were asked to stay

AGplusone: And some did.

DenvToday: They left to consolidate, then attack.

AGplusone: A friend of ours is Druse.

AGplusone: She left last year with her family. Said it was safe anymore.

geeairmoe2: I'm half-need, half-desire. Looking for a better life for one set of anschestors ...

geeairmoe2: ... escaping religious persecution from the other.

AGplusone: I think the Cubanos probably have been weeded a bit ... have some of the pioneer spirit, on both sides

AGplusone: of the Miami straits.

DenvToday: I never cease to admire the Cubans who take to those leaky rafts to come here.

fgherman: Even with all the hardship involved, I don't think there isn't a one of us who wouldn't help colonize

DenvToday: I know in my heart I would never have that kind of courage.

fgherman: space if we were allowed to go.

AGplusone: Odd, though, isn't it, the ones like the half of the Gonzalez family who stay ...

DenvToday: Felicia, true. lol

AGplusone: because it's their home.

AGplusone: The Reformers who stayed and fought the Cavaliers eventually.

AGplusone: "Roundheads" a generation or two later.

SAcademy: I heard an American ambassador today talking abaout what WE have done to others in the way of bombing

AGplusone: Which one?

fgherman: Remember, America was settled by folks who cut and run rather than stay and fight.

SAcademy: Can't remember his name.

geeairmoe2: Heard that, too. Don't know which ambassador it was.

DenvToday: Felicia, stay and fight who? There was no organized resistance. Cromwell was a generation later.

SAcademy: We've been bombing indiscriminately all over the globe.

geeairmoe2: Isn't the State Department types always the last to get on board?

AGplusone: Maybe his argument was 'bombing' doesn't solve anything. The only way you do it, is put troops

AGplusone: on the ground, and settle it finally.

fgherman: The Church of England, for example, with the Pilgrims

AGplusone: Do the Germans or the Japanese hate us today because we finally settled their hash

AGplusone: by invading and then occuping them for, in Germany's case, nearly a half century

fgherman: Maybe we should settle France's hash; they hate us

SAcademy: I doubt that they all love us.

BPRAL22169 has entered the room.

AGplusone: in Japan's for (if you count Okinawa) still that time too.

fgherman: I'm with Machiavelli on this one: better to be feared than loved.

AGplusone: I agree ...

DenvToday: Speaking of Japan...have any of you read Clancy's Debt of Honor?

geeairmoe2: Lived in Japan 70-73 and the older Japaneese still walked on eggshells around Americans.

AGplusone: Yes., of course.

AGplusone: Nice prediction, eh?

DenvToday: It was eerie.

joelrmpls has entered the room.

AGplusone: Evenin' Joel.

DenvToday: Hi Joel

fgherman: Hi sweetie

joelrmpls: Hi, all.

AGplusone: "sweetie"? You haven't been reading his posts! Nuclear warmonger!

SAcademy: Hello, Joel

geeairmoe2: Hello recent arrivals.

AGplusone: :-D

fgherman: You don't have to sleep with him

fgherman: :-)

AGplusone: some of us are lucky!

fgherman: besides, I mostly agree with him

AGplusone: The pioneering spirit leds to the same sort of spirit that some fear is lacking

geeairmoe2: Being a pioneer does take a certain kind of confident arrogance.

AGplusone: today in the polulace if we're to settle the 'terrorist' hash.

DenvToday: I have the pioneering spirit in abundance. What I lack is tolerance for any sort of discomfort.

geeairmoe2: The "Nothing can stop me" attitude.

DenvToday: Or danger.

AGplusone: leads

fgherman: We haven't been tested yet; you just watch

AGplusone: I listened to a cautionary program on PBS last night ... instant gratification won't cut it

WJaKe: Where on Earth is there to be a pioneer anymore?

AGplusone: was the point Moyer and others tried to make.

DenvToday: I'd be happy to pioneer any place with Good cigars and a Sizzler.

AGplusone: No surgical strikes will solve what's facing us.

DenvToday: David, I fear you're right.

AGplusone: The spirit of doing without new car models, putting up with rationing, etc., is what we need to know

AGplusone: we're going to face.

AGplusone: Same spirit as the pioneers.

AGplusone: Full mobilization ...

WJaKe: I think you're wrong. We have more economic backbone now then we had in WWII

AGplusone: war footing. No "great society" and war at the same time.

DenvToday: What good would that do? Sending 20 divisions to Afghanistan wouldn't solve a thing.

AGplusone: Maybe it won't take 1939-45, Jake, but you cannot expect guns and butter to work.

DenvToday: We need to bully governments into handing over the terrorists.

geeairmoe2: I've been waiting for some pundits on TV to talk about an economic war ...

AGplusone: How do you know, Denv. Because the Russians couldn't.

AGplusone: ?

geeairmoe2: ... everyone seems to concentrate on military options.

AGplusone: The Russians had to face a guerrilla war, and no guerrilla war has ever succeeded without outside supp

WJaKe: Because we don't need the kind and quantity of guns needed in the past

geeairmoe2: Cutting off their funds should be a first, bloodless option.

AGplusone: ort, which the Afghanstanis had. From us, and bin Laden.

joelrmpls: Yup; I sure am concentrating on military options, as a way of motivating proper political ones.

WJaKe: THis will be a covert "war", most likely, as there is no country to invade.

joelrmpls: Among other things.

joelrmpls: And, yes, I'm a nuclear warmonger.

AGplusone: Only way we wouldn't need the kind and quanities of arms and troops on the ground is if we used

geeairmoe2: I'd first option in a 'dinosuar', so that wavering allies could see what an accidental tail swipe ...

AGplusone: the nuclear or ABC options.

geeairmoe2: ... could do to them.

AGplusone: That's unacceptible for too many.

joelrmpls: I don't come to that casually, but in other places -- not here -- the option is apparently too icky...

DenvToday: We don't need to bomb population centers. We inform harboring governments that they will hand over...

joelrmpls: ... to discuss, and anybody who would is subhuman.

AGplusone: Because of the collateral effects.

geeairmoe2: Opps, sorry for that fallout. Who's side are you on again?

WJaKe: And you still don't know where to drop the A-bomb!

DenvToday: ...the terrorists. They can do this. If they don't, we start killing from the top up. We start...

joelrmpls: I could give you six targets, right now,


DenvToday: ...shooting presidents. Then Vice-presidents...then generals. Down the line.

DenvToday: top down, I meant.

WJaKe: But are you sure you will hit terrorists there?

AGplusone: I disagree about a covert war. I think the only way to win is occupy the ground.

joelrmpls: Oh, absolutely -- if you include "military and governmental headquarters of states that ...

fgherman: I wonder what Robert would have said?

AGplusone: Cf. Starship Troopers.

joelrmpls: ... have sponsored terrorism that has resulted in the deaths of US citizens."

AGplusone: "Navy types" always think differently, and they're wrong.

geeairmoe2: Since the Gulf too many people can't give up on the dream of a 'clean' war.

joelrmpls: Remember: this was a response to the US involvement in the Gulf War.

AGplusone: Johnson and Nixon thought "bomb Hanoi" or "bomb Cambodia" would win. They were wrong.

WJaKe: The Gulf War was too easy because it was too limited.

WJaKe: We won the battle without resolving the conflict.

DenvToday: I'm disturbed by the casual acceptance that police state restrictions on all of our lives will be...

DenvToday: ...necessary. Nobody seems outraged by that.

AGplusone: There were no 'police state' restrictions during WW2.

WJaKe: what sort of restrictions do you refer to? Let's talk specifics.

joelrmpls: And that's pretty much what's likely to happen, now -- at most, a restricted invasion of Afghanistan..

geeairmoe2: Terrorists need to look into the eyes of the soldiers who put the bullet into their foreheads.

fgherman: I know that a large number of us are concerned by that.

DenvToday: To protect our airplanes, it's very simple. Allow passengers to exercise their 2nd Amendment rights.

joelrmpls: ... and more talk about a "war on terrorism", that'll be about as effective as the "war on drugs."

AGplusone: The folk would lived in GBritain or the US were appalled when they found out what 'police state'

joelrmpls: But, let's say that we can wave a wand and make suicidal hijacking bombings impossible. Wave it. ok:

AGplusone: meant is eastern Europe under the communists, or in Germany, after the war, under the Nazis

joelrmpls: Do you think we've ended terrorism against the US?

AGplusone: "in" eastern Europe

AGplusone: No.

joelrmpls: What happens when, just to pick an example, OSB's buddies, still at loose -- or Arafat's -- hijack...

WJaKe: No, we wouldn't.

AGplusone: The only way to "end" terrorism is deny it a refuge ... north of the Yalu River

joelrmpls: ...a gasoline tanker, drive it to the Mall of America, where they meet their friends with the ...

geeairmoe2: A lot of me hopes we ended it, but most of me fears it'll get worse before it gets better.

joelrmpls: McVeigh-style bombs.

AGplusone: and the only way you end the refuge is occupy it.

AGplusone: Not bomb it.

WJaKe: so now we need to occupy China?

joelrmpls: I disagree, but I respect your opinion. I don't think that there would have been any refuge in, say,

AGplusone: Not fighting China, yet

joelrmpls: Tokyo if Harry Truman had decided to blow it up.

WJaKe: You're headed that way aren't you? north of the Yalu River?

geeairmoe2: One commentator mentioned some Europeans marvel at how we have public trash cans.

joelrmpls: From the Puppet Masters: "We're going to have to learn to live with this horror."

AGplusone: Today we're fighting Southwest Asian refuges

joelrmpls: The Israelis have, for years.

AGplusone: Figuratively speaking, Jake, yes.

WJaKe: I thought we were fighting Mid-Eastern ex-patriates.

AGplusone: Land at Haiffa, and proceed east.

geeairmoe2: The Phillipines have a Islamic terrorist problem, too.

joelrmpls: I think that the PA component of the problem is the easiest to handle, from the US POV.

AGplusone: then solve it in its time

WJaKe: PA?

AGplusone: if the Filipinos cannot handle it

joelrmpls: How about the Bekaa? Syria? the Emirates? Libya? Sudan? Cuba?

DenvToday: Pennsylvania. We wipe out Pennsylvania.

fgherman: Palestinian "Authority"

DenvToday: Oh.

joelrmpls: PA = "Palestinian Authority" Arafat's police state.

geeairmoe2: Someone expert, quiote confident, said Isreal can handle the PA and Hammas ...

WJaKe: But I thought Arafat was appaled at errorism, denounced it in every way!

geeairmoe2: ... if the US would allow them.

WJaKe: er, terrorism.

joelrmpls: But remember, unless we restrict ourselves to Al Quiada, we're talking about a dozen states.

AGplusone: Coming back from Philadelphia, considering the weather, maybe we should wipe out Pennsylvania ...

AGplusone: while we're at it. ;-)

fgherman: Take a lot of pesky relatives of mine

joelrmpls: As to Arafat being "appalled" about terrorism, actions speak louder than words, and he's deliberately

AGplusone: Mine too

geeairmoe2: There was a claim that bin Laden had cells in 55 countries. Some said 34.

joelrmpls: let known terrorists out of his jails.

joelrmpls: Cells are one thing -- I'm just talking about national entities that support Al Quaida. There's...

AGplusone: So, we tell 34 countries, stamp them out or we're coming in to stamp them out for you, or with you.

joelrmpls: ... at least Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq, and the Sudan.

AGplusone: I think the national entities are pretty easy to identify.

joelrmpls: And by "support", I don't mean just "cheer on."

WJaKe: Again, if you can find these cells.

AGplusone: That means remove the governments of Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq and the Sudan, etc., and replace them

AGplusone: with Adenhauers.

joelrmpls: Again: it's not the cells. We, manifestly, have an Al Quiada cell in Minnesota.

joelrmpls: Or, at least, had.

WJaKe: So replace the govt. of Minnesota?

joelrmpls: But I think it's fair to say that was without the support of the government of Minnesota.

AGplusone: If that means occupation, for the fifty years we've had NATO in Germany, then so be it.

DenvToday: Joel, I don't think the U.S. has the knowledge--or the will--to really attack terrorist groups.

joelrmpls: WJake, if you insist on refusing to acknowledge the difference between hidden terrorist cells...

geeairmoe2: The Russians never had mid-east terrorist problems. They had a unique solution...

WJaKe: :-DYeah, but I had to take at poke at Gov. The Mind

joelrmpls: ... and states that support terrorist organizations, there's really nothing we can talk about.

DenvToday: We'll give lip service, but that's all. Or we might wipe out one branch of the tree.

geeairmoe2: ... when a Russian was kidnapped, the next day the kidnappers received the ...

AGplusone: Clancy makes that point, Gee

geeairmoe2: ... body part of a close relative and a note suggesting many future deliveries.

ddavitt: sorry folks; hi to those who arrived after I left to feed the baby. I will have to go for good as

AGplusone: and I agree.

WJaKe: I do acknowledge the difference. That is what I see as the root problem, finding the hidden cells!

joelrmpls: It wasn't the next day; it took weeks, and at least one of the packages they sent included the body...

fgherman: Bye Jane

ddavitt: David is not yet back and I need to start cooking.

joelrmpls: of an infant girl.

ddavitt: Night.

DenvToday: Bye Jane

joelrmpls: Bye, Jane.

AGplusone: bye

geeairmoe2: Take care, Jane.

WJaKe: bye Jane

ddavitt has left the room.

joelrmpls: WJake, could you do something about that awful yellow color of your name?

DenvToday: The Israelis know. If we use Mossad, it could be done.

WJaKe: I don't know, it's red on my screen

DenvToday: We wouldn't even have to do it ourselves. All we would have to do is give the Israelis the go-ahead.

AGplusone: The problem is the (now it's blue, Jake)

fgherman: Your own name always shows up in red

joelrmpls: The issue of "extinguishing terrorist cells" <> "extinguishing the governments that support them"

geeairmoe2: I'm not sure Body Part Parcel Post would work with these guys, though.

AGplusone: 5 o'clock news.

joelrmpls: I'm not advocating that; I'm just pointing out that's what they did.

geeairmoe2: It would be worth a try.

joelrmpls: As to the Mossad, I'm not sure that they have accurate targetting information about terrorist...

WJaKe: I know joel, I agree with you on that, cells and govts.

joelrmpls: ...organizations in, say, Baghdad.

AGplusone: Maybe not. Joel and Clancy simply pointed out how the Russians made the targeting of Americans prefer-

AGplusone: able to targeting Russians.

joelrmpls: Of course it's preferable -- and we do all realize that OSB could have gotten a higher bodycount...

BPRAL22169: It seems to me if we could choke off bin Ladin's funding source -- Hussein -- the problem reduces

BPRAL22169: in size instantly.

joelrmpls: ... with just one plane, don't we?

joelrmpls: Funding, political support, all of that, sure.

AGplusone: Exactly, or his funding from Saudi Arabia, or Iraq, or Syria

geeairmoe2: Cut off his money, isolate known associates.

BPRAL22169: The consensus seems to be Hussein is the principal source.

AGplusone: that means destablilize those governments, and replace them

WJaKe: I thought OSB had inherited money?

AGplusone: Hussein gets his money from all those sources.

BPRAL22169: We don't have a particularly good record at placing puppet governments.

fgherman: Only 330 million

WJaKe: Or has burned up the several hundred million dollars mentioned/

AGplusone: Either they stop their subjects. Sure we do. Everyone forgets we replaced Hitler and Tojo

joelrmpls: ... but the Emirates are major contributors, too. You don't block a faucet with a fork.

geeairmoe2: Weren't we able to freeze a lot of Iranian assests during the hostage holding?

AGplusone: rather successfully.

AGplusone: We did that by all out war on those governments and by occupying the ground'

BPRAL22169: I rther thought Tojo reigned until his death.

joelrmpls: We did, but only after unconditional surrender, and a commitment to military occupation.

AGplusone: Why did he die, Bill.

AGplusone: ?

BPRAL22169: And we did not replace Hitler -- we accepted an existing government in place.

geeairmoe2: It goes directly to how willing are we to hold them to "You're either for us, or against us." ...

joelrmpls: Al Quaida is funded by, at least in part, the Emirates. Note that nobody is talking about action....

joelrmpls: .... against them.

BPRAL22169: You are right about Tojo -- I was thinking Hirohito.

DenvToday: Joel, there are many methods to stamp out terrorism. Some are better than others, but the essential..

geeairmoe2: ... what happens when an Afghani mother's starving baby shows up all over TV.

DenvToday: ...question is this: Does the U.S. have the will to actually do it? To get down and dirty?

AGplusone: What happened that enabled us to replace Hitler.

joelrmpls: Denv: Yup.

BPRAL22169: But assassinating a chief of staff is not the same as placing a puppet government.

AGplusone: We didn't accept the existing government, what remained after Hitler, we immediately put it on trial

AGplusone: and hanged most of it.

DenvToday: I hope you're right.

joelrmpls: Puppet governments are easy to do -- after unconditional surrender. Before, no.

joelrmpls: We actually hanged very, very little of it.

AGplusone: After we accepted its surrender.

joelrmpls: Take a look at the stats at Nuremberg sentences, sometime.

AGplusone: Well, now, what exactly happened to the guy who surrendered?

BPRAL22169: Doenitz?

AGplusone: Yes.

joelrmpls: He got off. Not the worse call ever made.

BPRAL22169: I think he had a short sentence.

DenvToday: Doenitz got ten years

BPRAL22169: I don't remember the specifics of the Nuremberg verdicts any more.

AGplusone: that took him out of action, didn't it?

BPRAL22169: Except a few -- Hess, Goering, etc.

joelrmpls: Take a look -- it might be very instructive, after you get past the few who were hanged.

fgherman: Beats hanging, though

AGplusone: We didn't exactly accept their government, did we?

joelrmpls: I'm in favor of giving Arafat a suspended sentence.

fgherman: Amen

AGplusone: Yes, we know, Joel.

geeairmoe2: I worry about the will of our MTV watching, video-game playing soldiers ...

DenvToday: Suspended over a gibbet?

geeairmoe2: ... will the stick it out.

BPRAL22169: Yes, we accepted the government and set up civil elections, with a military occupation interim

AGplusone: for how long?

joelrmpls: I'm not worried about the will of the military -- I am worried about the will of the US govt, and...

joelrmpls: ... the US population.

DenvToday: Joel, my point exactly.

BPRAL22169: I dont recall, exactly -- it was still going on when Patton died.

geeairmoe2: All of it, agreed.

AGplusone: In 1961 when I got there it was still an occupation, whether we recognized Konrad or not

BPRAL22169: "Denazification"

joelrmpls: ... and note how easily "denazification" was suspended, and for whom.

AGplusone: Whether we let Konrad have a little army or not

DenvToday: Pragmatism wins every time over noble philosophies.

DenvToday: That sounds cynical, but it's true.

joelrmpls: If there's a land war, the numbers of US servicemen coming home in bodybags will be huge.

WJaKe has left the room.

AGplusone: Today, the Seventh Army is still on the ground over there ...

fgherman: Ginny, you've lived through something like this before; do you think we have what it takes?

joelrmpls: Note that the leaders are talking in the vaguest generalities, and even qualifying those.

joelrmpls: See Wolfowitz's "clarification" yesterday.

AGplusone: Will they really? Didn't Hackman predict 10,000 casualties in Irag, Joel?

DenvToday: Yep. Lots of qualifying and revising going on today.

SAcademy: Sorry, I don't knnow whether we do have it any more Felicia.

AGplusone: yet the "Republican Guard" melted, didn't it?

DenvToday: I felt something of what we had then last week when I watched Band of Brothers. I went and looked...

joelrmpls: Dupuy predicted 300, mostly from friendly fire.

DenvToday: my father's Bronze Star. Something I hadn't done in years.

AGplusone: Hitler and Tojo both had a dedicated populance on their side. Gott Mit Uns!

AGplusone: Banzai!

joelrmpls: One of the reasons that I favor the nuclear option is that I don't think we have it.

AGplusone: Does bin Ladin have that?

AGplusone: Does Hussein have that?

joelrmpls: I do think the only way we can win, for a sufficiently serious value of "win", is ...

fgherman: He doesn't need it

joelrmpls: ...via a shortcut.

geeairmoe2: I worry about our current generation because the WWII generation were hardened by ...

AGplusone: Of course, not, in a terrorist war ... but I'm not talking about fighting a terrorist war.

geeairmoe2: ... the depression. The cureent generation's had no 'hardening'.

AGplusone: Agree, Will.

AGplusone: But is it really different?

DenvToday: Interesting side note: When we declared war on Japan, we didn't declare war on a nation.

geeairmoe2: They don't understand deprivation and sacrifice.

DenvToday: We declared war on one man--the Emporer.

AGplusone: That's the problem.

DenvToday: Emperor. Sorry.

joelrmpls: More depressing news: note how the Admin is lauding the Pakistanis, despite....

joelrmpls: ....them having rejected the most important US demand.

AGplusone: Is that today? I haven't watched the news today.

joelrmpls: Yup -- they've made it clear that they'll accept overflights, only. No US troops on...

joelrmpls: ...Pakistani soil.

AGplusone: What has Powell said? Or is it 'administration' voices only?

joelrmpls: State is dancing around whether or not we ever asked for that.

DenvToday: Yep Joel. I expected that.

geeairmoe2: We should remind of where we could stand should trouble with India crops up again.

joelrmpls: Oh, I think that we should abandon neutrality in India/Pakistan.

fgherman: "Go India"

joelrmpls: Yup.

joelrmpls: They've been living with this terror more than we have.

joelrmpls: If the Indians decide they need to take out Pakistani nuclear facilities, I think...

DenvToday: "I refuse to be impartial between the fire and the fire brigade." - W.S. Churchill

joelrmpls: ... we ought to provide targetting information, and air cover.

AGplusone: Well, India has its own problems regarding tolerance of other religions.

joelrmpls: I'm not saying that India is perfect -- quite the contrary. What I am saying is that...

AGplusone: I think the 'administration' better get told by its own citizenry that they better stop dancing

joelrmpls: ...we need to be much more generous about peccadilloes in our allies than we ...

joelrmpls: ...are about virtues in our enemies.

geeairmoe2: We ought to adopt that arab concept, the enemy of my enemy is my friend.

joelrmpls: Cuba, for example, has nearly 100% literacy. I think that's a good thing.

AGplusone: And then turn our armies on them after we finish off the radical Islamites, like Patton wanted, Joel?

joelrmpls: But are we serious about stopping terrorism? Or just AlQuida?

DenvToday: Joel, that was true of Nazi Germany as well.

joelrmpls: On India?

geeairmoe2: To get most of the world onboard, they may demand 'come help get our terrorists, too'.

joelrmpls: See "Solution Unsatisfactory".

AGplusone: See, To Sail Beyond the Sunset.

fgherman: And what's wrong with that?

AGplusone: President Patton

joelrmpls: We have the opposite of a creeping mission right now. We have the . . .

joelrmpls: ... constantly shrinking mission.

joelrmpls: Which will work only if it's sufficiently instructive.

geeairmoe2: Be longer and bloodier to solve everyone's problem, but worht it to our children. Goes back ...

joelrmpls: see

AGplusone: I think we should simply disestablish every government that sponsors terrorism against us.

fgherman: The thing that bothers me, is that no one really cared until someone other than Jews were being killed

geeairmoe2: ... to : do we have the guts to stick out to the end.

joelrmpls: I'm with you on that -- but note how many governments we have to disestablish...

joelrmpls: that principle.

AGplusone: And by disestablish I mean land troops on their soil and replace them.

joelrmpls: We don't have a tenth the troops needed to occupy them, not with full mobilization.

AGplusone: As I said, land at Haiffa and turn east.

AGplusone: Really?

geeairmoe2: We had a president the last 8 years kissing Arab rear and blocking Israel in an ...

geeairmoe2: attempt to get himself a Peace Prize.

AGplusone: We had enough troops in 45

joelrmpls: And that's forgetting, for a moment, the nontrivial problem of conquering them.

AGplusone: And our population was half that, and our armed forces were reduced.

joelrmpls: We had enough troops in 1945, to -- with the help of our allies -- occupy two non-resisting

joelrmpls: countries.

AGplusone: Well, who's going to help them resist?

joelrmpls: Both of which had been thoroughly conquered.

AGplusone: that's what I'm proposing

geeairmoe2: I worry about getting prepared. I live next to Ft. Hood, largest military base in the world ...

geeairmoe2: ... and training would be two, three days a week because of lack of equipment.

joelrmpls: I know you are.

AGplusone: Yes, just like 1940 and 41.

geeairmoe2: Soldiers had nothing substantive to do the rest of the time.

AGplusone: I'm talking full mobilization.

BPRAL22169 has left the room.

joelrmpls: Okay, how many divisions do we need to conquer, at a minimum, the following list:

AGplusone: Read the stories about training in 40 and 41 some day. Flour sacks, broomsticks, trucks labeled "tank"

AGplusone: 40 or 50

joelrmpls: Afghanistan, Pakistan, the Emirates, Iraq, Syria, Sudan, Cuba and Libya?

AGplusone: Leave Cuba out. We don't need to worry about them.

joelrmpls: Okay.

AGplusone: One peep out of you and thermonuclear war.

joelrmpls: I'll even throw out Sudan, just to be generous.

AGplusone: Green glass covers Cuba

geeairmoe2: I go back to suggest we had a better, more hardened pool of men for combat in 41 than today.

AGplusone: Maybe so, but there are a few good men around who can harden.

fgherman: No, we've got Gulf War veterans

AGplusone: Doesn't matter. They're good men.

joelrmpls: Oh, absolutely -- but we had more blooded officers available in Korea. Look at all the retreads...

joelrmpls: HST called up.

AGplusone: They know what can be done.

AGplusone: We have to have a Kaserine Pass.

joelrmpls: I'm not doubting their courage, or their professionalism. I am doubting the numbers.

geeairmoe2: I hope so, but I see everyday the idiots we have in the Army.

AGplusone: That is what hardens.

AGplusone: The idiots get shaken out.

joelrmpls: Let's just look at Syria -- probably one of the easier places to conquer.

AGplusone: No, let's let the military look at Syria. That's what they're paid for.

geeairmoe2: The everyday grunts? Scary. But then, its only the idiots that make the news here.

geeairmoe2: I just may be seeing that black spot and forgetting the big, white paper its on.

joelrmpls: Okay; if you don't want to do the thought experiment, I won't force you. :-)

AGplusone: They'll do the thought experiment if we tell them to.

AGplusone: That's their job.

AGplusone: But we have to have the will to tell them and to follow through.

joelrmpls: Sure, they will. But it'll still take n number of soldiers to conquer a country of m millions.

fgherman: Hear, hear

AGplusone: That's what we're talking about "pioneer spirit"

joelrmpls: What if m < our total possible mobilization?

joelrmpls: Err, make that "what if n < our total possible mobilization"?

geeairmoe2: Its just that if what we have to use is what I've seen at Ft. Hood, it might be a high number.

AGplusone: We cannot have guns and butter ....

joelrmpls: Agreed.

geeairmoe2: Then again, the sight of that rubble in NYC might be the hardening we've lacked.

AGplusone: We can field eight armored division and 22 infantry divisions in a year if we do it.

joelrmpls: But let's assume that we're willing to lower our enlistment standards, and include, say, 47-year old

joelrmpls: ... fat guys with diabetes.

AGplusone: running Remingtons, sure

geeairmoe2: How tied in is the will the fight with the numbers needed.

fgherman: And their wives

joelrmpls: I'll accept your numbers on the divisions -- but how many did the Nazis have in the Balkans, alone?

AGplusone: it's the will ... I don't hear day that will live in infamy ... I don't hear declarations of war.

joelrmpls: Me, neither.

AGplusone: DivisionsWW 2 have nothing to do with Divisions today

joelrmpls: Except from Bob Barr, may his tribe increase.

geeairmoe2: Maybe the paranoia about the various citizen militias will drop a little.

joelrmpls: Okay -- how many of those thirty divisions do you think we need for Afghanistan, alone?

AGplusone: Almost as bad as armor battalions against one MI

AGplusone: All of them.

AGplusone: Clancy argues in his one recent Bear and whatever it was, that an Armor Division is sufficient today

joelrmpls: Which means, therefore, that we don't have enough for the other countries that need...

AGplusone: to do what at least a Corps did in WW 2

joelrmpls: ... the same attention.

joelrmpls: Oh, in terms of firepower vs. an enemy military, sure.

AGplusone: Not planning to land in Afghanistan first, Joel. First, as I said, you land at Haiffa.

geeairmoe2: Have we totally abandoned the 'war on two fronts' strategy?

AGplusone: And you clean out North Africa.

joelrmpls: Better watch out -- the natives will be throwing chocolate bars to the soldiers. :-)

AGplusone: Then you move on ...

geeairmoe2: In terms of prepardedness.

fgherman: lol

fgherman: Kosher ones

AGplusone: If the Russians want to join the fun and come in through the north, no one's going to say No.

joelrmpls: (Although I think Haifa would be suboptimal; Gaza could be cleared for the necessary...

joelrmpls: ...facilities by the time the ships arrived.

AGplusone: Haiffa is figuerative

joelrmpls: I know. :-)

fgherman: Ahh, 2 birds with one stone.

AGplusone: The point is: you clean out the area

joelrmpls: But I am trying to get a picture for how you think that the area *might* be cleaned out...

AGplusone: Stop off in Bagdad on the way

joelrmpls: conventional forces, and how many you think it would take.

geeairmoe2: I actually so some airheads suggesting this wouldn't have happened if we weren't supportive of Israel.

AGplusone: Say hi to Hassein ....

geeairmoe2: Heard some airhead. My fingers are fading fast.

joelrmpls: Baghdad would be a hard nut to crack. Not impossible, mind you.

AGplusone: Was in reach in about 24 hours ten years ago.

joelrmpls: Oh, lots of airheads are suggesting this. Read rasff, if you've got the stomach for it.

geeairmoe2: rasff?

joelrmpls: Sure -- was in reach. And with the Republican Guard as badly shattered as it was...

fgherman: rec.arts.sf.fandom

joelrmpls: ...even Dupuy was saying that the casualties of a ground assault would be huge.

AGplusone: And the Republican Guard shattered pretty quickly.

AGplusone: yeah, well, lots of folk said casualties would be heavy.

joelrmpls: And that's just Baghdad.

AGplusone: We'll never know, will we?

AGplusone: And that took, what, 100 hours?

fgherman: If we'd been more supportive of Israel, this wouldn't have happened.

AGplusone: and a preparatory bombardment of what, two months?

joelrmpls: Sure. But an incompetent enemy, led by a military nutcase, isn't the worse opposition to face.

geeairmoe2: Whats the possiblity of one wellplaced nuke bringing the other countries around?

AGplusone: Who said any of the dictators are not military nutcases, all of them?

AGplusone: Do any of them have the German general staff handy?

joelrmpls: Oh, I think that the military dictator of Pakistan, for example, has apparently got some riffs.

AGplusone: Or the Imperial Japanese General Staff, hardened by conquering most of China.

joelrmpls: Thankfully, the German General Staff was handicapped by the Fuhrer.

AGplusone: We don't need nukes, unless Pakistan is stupid enough to employ them against us.

AGplusone: And I don't think Pakistan will last that long.

joelrmpls: And, to take another example, the Syrians have gotten a lot better since 1967, as...

joelrmpls: ....they demonstrated in 1973.

AGplusone: so ....

joelrmpls: As to the nukes, my guess is that if Kabul and Islamabad go, and the US expresses regret...

AGplusone: Are they going to stand up against us, the Brits, the French, the Israelis ...

joelrmpls: ...only for the necessity, that's all it would take for surrender of all the countries on the list.

AGplusone: the Turks

SAcademy: Nite, all. Gotta run

joelrmpls: The French won't mobilize to invade anybody -- at most, they'll send a couple of active divisions.

SAcademy has left the room.

joelrmpls: Night, ginny.

fgherman: Is having the French a help or a hindrance?

AGplusone: Maybe so ... maybe not. A couple armored divisions will help. The French aren't a great army

AGplusone: good at surrendering

joelrmpls: Oh, I dunno -- they surrender real, real purty.

joelrmpls: Damn. You beat me to it.

fgherman: (lol)

AGplusone: But we can use the foreign legion

geeairmoe2: One wag said: The French don't care if Americans are killed, but when their own people die ...

AGplusone: We used it in Desert Strike

geeairmoe2: ... French were among those killed in the towers.

AGplusone: Exactly, they may have to go along.

joelrmpls: Sure. But just, randomly, assuming that we can beat any army by matching numbers of divisions...

AGplusone: I don't assume anything.

geeairmoe2: There was a real good, utterly obscene comment about the French. Wish I could remember it.

geeairmoe2: The fight with their feet and f**k with their face, I think it was.

joelrmpls: Ok. I'll stop blueskying numbers now.

JudyjediJudy has entered the room.

AGplusone: But I don't assume that anything Syria, Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, or anyone else ....

fgherman: Welcome Judy

AGplusone: Hi, "filly"?

JudyjediJudy: Hi Felicia.

joelrmpls: That's "Mommy" to you, young lady!

fgherman: That's "Mom" to you.

JudyjediJudy: Okay , Okay.

geeairmoe2: I had an uncle always telling DeGaulle jokes to me because I was born in France.

joelrmpls: *whap!*

Merfilly8 has entered the room.

AGplusone: Hi, Stephanie.

geeairmoe2: No, I'm not French. Army brat.

AGplusone: We're fighting WW III against the middle east

geeairmoe2: My favorite joke was: DeGaulle died today. He got hit by a speedboat while trying to walk on water.

fgherman: Hi Stephanie

AGplusone: started by talking about 'pioneer spirit' and is it dead, and transitioned into this

JudyjediJudy: (lol)

Merfilly8: Hello all

Musiquelle26 has entered the room.

AGplusone: I read some of RAH's letters to Campbell in Grumbles, ca. December 41, and on ...

Merfilly8 has left the room.

AGplusone: and had to wonder what his feelings would be.

geeairmoe2: Same outrage, I'd guess.

geeairmoe2: Immedietly look for some way to help the war effort.

Musiquelle26 has left the room.

AGplusone: Is there really any choice in what our response should be here?

JudyjediJudy: Nope.

AGplusone: Do we just cosmetically engage in a reprisal and go back to business .... as usual, and wait for the

AGplusone: next time?

AGplusone: Or do we actually deliberately set out to replace governments that support terrorism?

geeairmoe2: I like a big, showy splash that makes any potential fence-sitters think REAL hard.

joelrmpls: I think we take a "middle course". I think we replace the Taliban, and make some noises.

AGplusone: "Why do today, what you can put off to tomorrow?"

AGplusone: I think we'll do that unless we continue to send outraged letters to shrub

DJedPar: Shrub?

AGplusone: Really outraged letters.

AGplusone: Bush, Jr.

joelrmpls: And I think that we institute a whole bunch of "domestic security" precautions...

joelrmpls: ... that are the equivalent of closing all Sbarros in Israel.

geeairmoe2: Cut back on that 'Shrub' bit or you'll get an outraged letter from me. :-)

AGplusone: aka "Dazed and confused" ... I feel like a republican in 41, thinking I have to close ranks on the

AGplusone: traitor to my class.

Musiquelle26 has entered the room.

joelrmpls: I think he's going to have to live with that, just like "Landslide Lyndon" did.

AGplusone: :-)

joelrmpls: As to what we should do, I've been clear on that, and don't need to repeat it.

DJedPar: Where is Piaf when you need her?

geeairmoe2: Okay, instead of what SHOULD we do, what WILL we do?

geeairmoe2: Predictions.

joelrmpls: As I said: I think what we will do is engage in a military operation that might:

AGplusone: I hope, pray we do what we should do.

joelrmpls: a) get bin Laden

geeairmoe2: (I feel like McLughlin)

joelrmpls: b) destabilize the Taliban.

joelrmpls: and, and most c) occupy Afghanistan.

joelrmpls: I think that the other terrorist nations will, at worst, suffer some economic sanctions.

joelrmpls: And diplomatic ones, too.

fgherman: Alas

joelrmpls: "We've recalled our Ambassador, Mr. Assad. Now you'll tremble!"

joelrmpls: "And today, my fellow Americans, I've sent a stiff note to Muamar Ghaddffi."

AGplusone: I do not think it makes military sense to do (c) unless you remove the threats to your rear and flanks

geeairmoe2: I think that pretty well nails it. Will it be enough.

AGplusone: and that means Syria, Iraq, and probably Pakistan.

joelrmpls: Agreed. but I'm not talking about what makes military sense, but what I think we'll do.

AGplusone: Unless there's a coup in Pakistan.

geeairmoe2: For me, the two unknows seem to be: Do we have the will to do?

AGplusone: We cannot do that. Powell will not allow it.

geeairmoe2: And will the fence-sitters come quickly to our side.

joelrmpls: 50-50, the agreement to overflights will trigger that, assuming that we use the airspace.

AGplusone: Unless Powell gets the ducks in a row, there will be no invasion of Afghanistan ...

joelrmpls: Will it be enough? Enough for what?

joelrmpls: Shut down the Arab terror network? Nah.

geeairmoe2: How much is the Syria leadership and military tied together. Can we see a coup there?

AGplusone: Overflights aren't sufficient. We'll either get nothing but gestures, or we'll get:

AGplusone: "Well, now we're going to land troops in Pakistan. Either with us or 'agin' us, Pakistan? What's it

AGplusone: going to be?"

joelrmpls: Felicia just point out that I'm not the only person in the world advocating nuclear strikes.

geeairmoe2: I know Saddem and the Iraqi military are one and the same.

joelrmpls: htm

geeairmoe2: I'll join that list.

AGplusone: I'm sure Jerry Falwell is advocating strikes too, Joel; but Jerry IIRC had his daddy's congressman

AGplusone: pull him off the boat into Inchon Harbor.

TAWN3 has entered the room.

joelrmpls: Actually, Jerry Falwell isn't. He explains that the problem is all the abortion-advocating lesbians.

TAWN3: Hi all

AGplusone: Hi, Tawn ... welcome to the WW III in the middle east sipping and chowder club

DenvToday: Hello Tawn

DJedPar: Hi Tawn

fgherman: Hello Tawn

AGplusone: nice to have someone who's going to have to do it with us. They call you up yet, Captain?

TAWN3: No, not yet.

TAWN3: Expect to be though.

fgherman: Anything that we can do to help?

TAWN3: Give blood.

TAWN3: :-)

fgherman: Will do

joelrmpls: Red Cross says to call this week; I checked this morning.

Musiquelle26: I was asked to come back next week, with an appointment at the blood center

TAWN3: Yes, response has ben good all over the country.

fgherman: Especially with those "cold, unfeeling New Yorkers"

joelrmpls: The US culture gives good warmth, at least in a crisis.

AGplusone: It was nice to know that the Philly Red Cross immediately shipped our blood north to NYC on 9/11

joelrmpls: That's a virtue, but it's not the only virtue needed, right now.

Musiquelle26: I stand among the awed that our country does work well in times of crisis.

AGplusone: Forgetting for a moment that you're a reserve officer, what do you think the response should be, Tawn?

TAWN3: It's our strength.

Musiquelle26: I'm too young to remember anything approaching the unity I have seen lately.

AGplusone: Is it time to put an end to terrorist governments in the Muddle East?

fgherman: It's been along time since we've needed to be this united.

Musiquelle26: Muddle fits

TAWN3: In my personal opinion, yes.

geeairmoe2: The U.S. is like brothers who will wail upon one another, but God help some outsider doing it.

fgherman: Way past time

AGplusone: Yes, I mistyped, corrected, and then retyped the error.

joelrmpls: In other news, Iran has closed its border with Afghanistan.

Musiquelle26: good

joelrmpls: They feel that they have enough Afghani refugees, already.

geeairmoe2: To keep out refugees.

AGplusone: Oh, yeah ... the Imanis are saying: "Count us out of this!"

joelrmpls: Yup -- they're buddies, you see, but not that kind of buddies.

TAWN3: Is Afghan Shii?

AGplusone: We'll send them arms ... if we can get away with it.

TAWN3: I suppose I should know that, hadn't thought to find out before

geeairmoe2: Whichever is more radical, Shii or Suni, that's Afghanistan.

Musiquelle26: I don't think so

joelrmpls: Mainly Sunni; about 15% Shiites.

joelrmpls: "Religions: Sunni Muslim 84%, Shi'a Muslim 15%, other 1%"

AGplusone: Shii down south in the marches that Kissinger and Bush left to hang.

TAWN3: Ok. I usually think of Persians as Shiite

AGplusone: marshes

joelrmpls: Persians are, largely, Shiite.

joelrmpls: Afghans are sort of Persian Lite.

joelrmpls: "Less cultured, more violent."

joelrmpls: I've got to go make dinner now; later, all.

AGplusone: later

TAWN3: Shiites (Persians) say the Arabs broke the chain of succession with the seventh "ruler"

joelrmpls has left the room.

fgherman: Good night all. I've got to help him make dinner.

TAWN3: So, in a strict sense, by definition, Shiite is the more politically radical

fgherman has left the room.

Musiquelle26: On a semi-related note, what happened with the trials the Taliban was holding of those

TAWN3: But that's different

Musiquelle26: relief workers?

JudyjediJudy: I'm leaving.

JudyjediJudy has left the room.

AGplusone: Which ones? the UN types?

BPRAL22169 has entered the room.

AGplusone: Or the indigenious citizens?

geeairmoe2: There have been veiled threats to retaliation against foriegners.

Musiquelle26: THe ones who allegedely advocated Christianity, The UN type

TAWN3: Hey Joel, that was good! Persian lite. :-)

AGplusone: UN evacuated yesterday ... all of them.

Musiquelle26: I have not had ten minutes to myself until this evening, unfortunately

AGplusone: How's everyone, Stephanie?

AGplusone: {or all that could get out}

AGplusone: Ebon?

BPRAL22169 has left the room.

Musiquelle26: Paula's still doing well, no more treatments, Kevin's recovering froma torn calf, and the

Musiquelle26: babies are yard apes now

AGplusone: Good.

AGplusone: a remission then, I take it?

Musiquelle26: We'll know for sure in a few weeks when she does her post check-up

AGplusone: crossing fingers

Musiquelle26: But it looked favorable on the end-treatment biopsy

TAWN3: Did anyone read L. Niel Smith's commentary the day of the attack?

AGplusone: I haven't. You have a link?

DenvToday: Do you have a link?

TAWN3: Someone posted it on the Heinleiners list, I'll dig it up and send it to you

AGplusone: okay ....

DenvToday: tyvm

TAWN3: Basically, he was predicting that we would all be instantly ruled by a police state

TAWN3: immediately as a result of the attacks.

Musiquelle26: I have a question, and I hope no one gets upset, but I'm trying to catch impressions

TAWN3: It was divorced from reality IMHO

Musiquelle26: What was everyone's first, non-thought reaction?

geeairmoe2: Some libertarians may have made a serious PR blunder bringing that up so fast after the bombing.

TAWN3: We were at war.

AGplusone: Funny, tho ... he just sent out a take-off on Harry Bellefonte's Day-Oh, called ....

geeairmoe2: Made it look like all they cared about was their own personal needs.

geeairmoe2: And nothing for 5,000 innocent dead.

AGplusone: "The Pay Back Song" ....

AGplusone: Some libertarians need to have their heads spaced, which is why I ain't one.

AGplusone: Pearl Harbor, Filly.

TAWN3: And timed David, don't forget the timing.

AGplusone: That too

TAWN3: Yeah, I thought Pearl Harbor as well.

geeairmoe2: I was wondering, like with Pearl Harbor lore, how long before someone claims ...

AGplusone: Wait until we have the mass funerals.

geeairmoe2: ... the government let them bomb the towers for some political reason.

TAWN3: No one has any idea what we are talking about :-)

AGplusone: Filly knows.

TAWN3: Did anyone see the Father Mike funeral today? That was the most moving service I have ever

TAWN3: seen I think.

Musiquelle26: I had just gotten to work, and the last guy in said "A plane crashed into the WTC"

AGplusone: Head spacing and timing is what you do with a .50 cal. to make sure it doesn't blow up in your face

AGplusone: when you fire it.

Musiquelle26: I thought he was making a sick joke, but went to pull it up on the internet

DJedPar: Lots of people behave irrationally/improperly in time of crisis.

geeairmoe2: I was thinking spacing and timing had something to do with spark plugs.

AGplusone: My wife woke me up into the middle of it.

Musiquelle26: We listened to AM radio all day at work, because we had no tv coverage

AGplusone: First thought was: Bush is going to get out of the economy mess because of this, then we saw it was

AGplusone: very serious, and oh-oh.

TAWN3: However, you can't account for operator headspace!

AGplusone: No, you cannot.

TAWN3: Forgat to send that off before.

geeairmoe2: My father, works Physical Security (Customs) at Ft. Hood, called. It was after the second ...

geeairmoe2: ... plane hit the its tower. What really numbed me was seeing the tower collapse.

AGplusone: Yes, that happened right after I got the first cup of tea into me.

DenvToday: Same here. I thought there would be a gash in the tower and that woudl be it.

DenvToday: When I saw the tower collapse, I got light-headed. Unreal. Couldn't belive it.

TAWN3: Yes, I saw that live. It was all raher shocking.

AGplusone: And when I saw it pancake I knew there'd be thousands dead.

Musiquelle26: I felt shock, then anger.

AGplusone: a real cold rage

Musiquelle26: yes

AGplusone: and then fear that no one would do anything real about it.

TAWN3: I'm surprised the death count is so low. That says a lot for US construction and society.

AGplusone: And that's what scares me today.

AGplusone: It does.

Musiquelle26: From what we hear, the evacuation was going rapidly and in a controlled manner

TAWN3: What is that David?

AGplusone: I thought 40k for sure.

Musiquelle26: So did we

TAWN3: I did too.

DenvToday: It's going to be about 6 thousand dead all told.

AGplusone: The fear that our leaders will piddle fuck around this thing.

geeairmoe2: I was hopefully optimistic, thinking there had been time for many, many to make it out.

Musiquelle26: We overestimated the plane deaths and could not fathom how many in the towers

DJedPar: You are correct AG, unfortunately.

TAWN3: No. I'm afraid of just the opposite David.

AGplusone: Send in a few missles and say: "See, we showed them!"

AGplusone: What opposite, Tawn?

TAWN3: No, no way. Congress and the administration all take this far to serious

AGplusone: A precipitous invasion?

TAWN3: I hope we don't go to far and stat a universal Jihad.

Musiquelle26: Solid airstrikes accompanied by ground forces is what many here want

TAWN3: I don't think we will, but....

TAWN3: No, we need to invade.

AGplusone: I think we have to take them one at a time.

AGplusone: "With us, or agin' us?" Next country: "With us, or agin' us?" Next country: etc. and ditto.

TAWN3: We need to wipe out the entire structure of terror networks.

AGplusone: We do.

Musiquelle26: Declare an "Enemies of USA list, and check them all off with decisive action

AGplusone: Sure. Just like the old Attorney Generals' list of organizations.

geeairmoe2: I think it was Wm F Buckley who advocated, take out a known enemey and if they weren't ...

AGplusone: There's no free speech issue.

AGplusone: They're not citizens, and there's a clear imminent danger.

geeairmoe2: ... responsible, apoligize and move on to the next enemy.

Musiquelle26: I want to see retribution in the form of military action.

AGplusone: I agree with Buckley for the first time in years.

AGplusone: But no one ever accused him of being unable to think clearly.

TAWN3: once we attack, it will be all out war, terrorists will throw everything they have at us

AGplusone: I want to see an occupation like that of Germany.

TAWN3: once they realize it is "use it or lose it".

AGplusone: They will.

AGplusone: Just as Hitler landed those subs in North Carolina.

geeairmoe2: The problem with occupation is you provide a target for every little piss-ant radical.

DenvToday: I would rather them throw everything they have at us now rather than ten years from now when they...

DenvToday: ...have nukes.

DenvToday: If they had nukes now, they would have used them.

AGplusone: Yes, but ... there has to be support for guerrillas from the exterior.

AGplusone: I agree.

TAWN3: No, you can't occupy Afgan for long. Brits and Soviets found that out.

geeairmoe2: And if you get them all, you don't need to occupy. But a nice little nuke :-)

AGplusone: Don't need to occupy it long, and don't need to nuke it.

TAWN3: Exactly David.

TAWN3: Taliban is not universally loved in Afghan, and has commited crimes against humanity, such

AGplusone: Get it. Clear out the Taliban, get out, and leave them to their business.

geeairmoe2: One nuke, to underscore our seriousness. Not so much to kill the radicals ...

TAWN3: as destroying Bamiyan, which REALLY pissed me off!

AGplusone: Forget about nation building.

geeairmoe2: ... as to get the fencesitters formly with us.

AGplusone: NO nukes, unless we have to take out something when we invade.

TAWN3: I agree david, with nation building and aid to follow.

AGplusone: We don't need to use nukes unless we have a Harry Truman choice.

TAWN3: Or throw them to the Russians!

TAWN3: Say, hey, Putin, thanks for the support, they're all yours now. LOL

AGplusone: 'making points' doesn't ever, Will.

AGplusone: How do you scare a populance that hasn't a pot to piss in with a nuke?

geeairmoe2: Making points to those still rational.

AGplusone: There's no one rational in that country.

TAWN3: David, I disagree about nation building. After we do it, we have to help stabilize it.

TAWN3: Or the same problem will pop up.

AGplusone: Well, I think there's a possibility that trying to nation build will just turn us into 'oppressors'

AGplusone: for every tinpot demogogue.

AGplusone: Leave them to their goats ....

DenvToday: I still say we kill from the top down. The traditional way has been to kill thousands of soldiers...

TAWN3: Not do so while occupyinmg. This time, unlike Saudi, Get out.

DenvToday: ...and civilians to get to the top dog. Why do that?

AGplusone: I think top down is what we do when we occupy.

DenvToday: Kill heads of state.

AGplusone: Sift out the chaff, and destroy it and then leave.

TAWN3: Half of the problem today., if not more, is because we never left after the Gulf War.

AGplusone: Your village is yours again. See to it it stays that way. Bye.

DenvToday: Ask politely for the terrorists groups in their country. Give them 24 hours. Then ask the guys...

Musiquelle26: Thank you for an echo of opinion, Tawn

DenvToday: ...who has replaced the head of state we killed.

AGplusone: I agree with you Denv.

DenvToday: He'll be remarkably compliant, I'd say.

TAWN3: Sure Musiq.

AGplusone: and after we get two or three refusals, we declare war. Let them sit there looking foolish while we

AGplusone: build up. Send them photos of the building up.

AGplusone: Problem is: how do you get to the leaders when they go to the bush.

TAWN3: David, don't forget, it's not just the Taliban. It's Sudan, probably Yemen, many others, as

geeairmoe2: Sooner or later, nation building or no, we're going to have to leave, and it would help prevent ...

TAWN3: well as states who support it on the side, such as Iran.

DenvToday: Are we ready to get nasty?

geeairmoe2: ... having to do it all again if they had something indelible imprinted on their psyche that ...

TAWN3: We need to go into many places.

DenvToday: I mean really nasty?

DenvToday: You go after their families.

geeairmoe2: ... demonstrates what happen if you fall into bad habits.

AGplusone: I pointed out to Joel my theory. Land in Haifa, and start moving East. Clear out the whole muddle.

DenvToday: Do as we tell you to do or your children get it.

DenvToday: I know that sounds barbaric...

DenvToday: ...but is it less barbaric to kill ten thousand soliders to get to thim?

Musiquelle26: But has little effect Denv

TAWN3: Soviet style.

Musiquelle26: In certain cultures, the promise of eternal reward outweighs such mortal insult

geeairmoe2: I mentioned earlier, when I lived in Japan in the early 70's, how the Japaneese who remembered ...

geeairmoe2: ... the bomb wlaked on egshells around Americans.

AGplusone: I don't think you have time to educate the populace. they won't know what you're talking about

geeairmoe2: I was a ten-year old kid and they moved out of the way for me.

TAWN3: Well, we had the Sun od, MacArtjur, who played the role to the max geeairmoe.

TAWN3: Sun God.

AGplusone: All they know is what their Iman says.

geeairmoe2: 25 years after the bomb they were respectful to teenage American.

AGplusone: Wasn't just a bomb, Will?

TAWN3: It's a Third World country. Backwards. Unfortuneately.

geeairmoe2: Probaly different now, a generation later.

AGplusone: They were soundly beaten, theatre wide.

geeairmoe2: They had had they homeland violated. That made the real impression.

TAWN3: Japan? Yes, and the Emperor bowed down. THAT was humbling.

AGplusone: And it's a different situation ... the homeland violated, exactly.

AGplusone: Same thing with the Germans.

Musiquelle26: I started reading the Koran recently, as I said on the board

AGplusone: We sat there, for fifty-odd years, now.

TAWN3: Afghan is not Japan. Be careful of comparisons except in the most basic, macro sense.

geeairmoe2: If we violate the homeland of friends of terrorists, they'll remember that.

AGplusone: I agree, but not by simply bombing it.

geeairmoe2: I'm talking about what we do to their supporters.

TAWN3: Third world versus 1st world mentality. Big difference.

geeairmoe2: Get them on our side quickly.

AGplusone: I agree. Nuremburg.

Musiquelle26: And I am have had to put it aside, due to the recent events.

AGplusone: Take them out and shoot them.

geeairmoe2: How do you think Yemen will react to the sight of a mushroom cloud over Afghanistan.

Musiquelle26: No one wants to tolerate even an attempt to become educated about the beliefs

AGplusone: But the problem is going to be: what do we do about the Saudis who have been doing this.

geeairmoe2: Think they'll stop blocking the Cole investigation?

TAWN3: Well, how about with a Jihad Geeairmoe

AGplusone: Yemen would declare a holy war against us. What do they have to lose?

geeairmoe2: For the Saudis, just destroy all their oil wells.

AGplusone: You don't scare someone who has nothing with bombs.

TAWN3: Saudis are allies.

geeairmoe2: We've got more nukes than the terrorists have friendly countries.

AGplusone: Most are, Tawn, but what about the bin Ladens?

TAWN3: See, this is what I am afraid of, over reaction.

AGplusone: Nukes aren't going to do shit.

DenvToday: David, I agree.

Musiquelle26: Or worse, the ones suspected of talking out of both sides their mouths?

TAWN3: You don't destroy saudi oil wells because of a Saudi criminal.

DavidWrightSr: All it would do is create a million new terrorists!

AGplusone: except piss people off.

TAWN3: By the way, we are the ones who want the oil don't forget.

DenvToday: Besides--we need the oil. We'd be cutting our own throats.

DenvToday: lol hyep

DenvToday: yep

AGplusone: You don't use a nuke unless you have a Harry Truman choice, do I lose 250,000 men invading.

geeairmoe2: Convince me we won't lose 250,000 without nukes.

TAWN3: We have the moral highground. We need to keep it. Period.

DavidWrightSr: Tactical nukes against an opposing army? That might be needed.

DenvToday: We discover exactly where the terrorist camps are. We use the Israelis. We find out where the...

DavidWrightSr: But against a populated center just to give them the fear of God. No way.

AGplusone: How can I convince you? 100 hour war against Iraq enough for you?

DenvToday: terrorist leaders are hiding out. We can do this.

DenvToday: Then we go in and get them. We don't use large invasion forces. We use commandos.

AGplusone: The vaunted Republican Guard melted into the woodwork.

DenvToday: And we don't ask permission of the countries we enter. We just go in and get th em.

TAWN3: The Republican Guard was smart. they lived to fight another day.

TAWN3: And are still in power.

geeairmoe2: Take out the fund raisers, take out the country's that offer sancuary.

AGplusone: It didn't have to be that way. We didn't have to stop.

TAWN3: Agreed, in many ways David. Except,

geeairmoe2: Put in everyone's mind, now and forever: support terrorists, get nuked.

geeairmoe2: Give everyone the undeniable incentive to never harbor terrorists.

AGplusone: Love it, the nuke mentality.

TAWN3: I've always thouht showing our true honesty to the Russians was a big reason wwe stopped.

AGplusone: True terrorism.

geeairmoe2: Getting the terrorist alone is just half the problem.

AGplusone: To get one, we'll kill ten thousand.

geeairmoe2: Look at those dancing Palestinians who taught math by, if you kill three jews then four ...

AGplusone: Problem is: the nuke kills the ones appalled by the dancing.

geeairmoe2: More terrorists will be born, and our great grandchildren won't face this problem.

DenvToday: I must be going. Bye everybody. Thanks for the excellent discussion.

geeairmoe2: We left the Gulf War half done, we can't leave the eradication of terrorism half done.

AGplusone: But you don't do it with Nukes.

DenvToday has left the room.

geeairmoe2: That's what I'm talking about when "the will to see it through".

geeairmoe2: If you can suggest something that can leave a more indeliable impression, I'm with you.

AGplusone: Tell you what, Gee. You agree to ride the Nuke down, and I will think about it.

TAWN3: Bye Denv.

TAWN3: Agree Geeair. Can't be a half ass job.

TAWN3: Must be all out.

AGplusone: After all, it's just a little demonstration on an unimportant town or two.

TAWN3: YEE HAH! Slim pickens!

AGplusone: or John Ezra Dalquist

DavidWrightSr: If it would work, I might agree. But it *will not* work. It will just leave...

Musiquelle26: I find myself sensitive to the idea of nukes, I must admit

DavidWrightSr: millions of terrorists around to get us later.

TAWN3: NO NUKES ARE NEEDED. I can't believe I am hearing this.

DavidWrightSr: *create* millions of terrorists to get us.

AGplusone: exactly: my name is Jose Jimenez, you killed my father: prepare to die.

Musiquelle26: Of all that I have heard, the idea of surgical, commando type strikes fit my idea of just

AGplusone: surgical strikes are a joke

AGplusone: we were doomed by that thinking in Vietnam

TAWN3: Exactly Musiq. Surgical with supporting ground forces. NOT a stupid air war only.

DavidWrightSr: Like the one in Iran to get the hostages out

AGplusone: tea saloon idiots and newscasters

Musiquelle26: I apologize; I have little grounding in the concept of works well

TAWN3: I must sign off for a few moments

Musiquelle26: I just want to minimize how much like them we must go to get the job done

AGplusone: to do it you must land forces and take and hold the ground ...

AGplusone: You can't.

TAWN3: If I can't sign off before you all quit, good seeing you all!

geeairmoe2: Forgive me for caring so much for the future generations of my country thal I'll do anything....

AGplusone: See you, Tawn.

TAWN3 has left the room.

geeairmoe2: ... ANYTHING to protect them.

AGplusone: No. Doing anything is unforgiveable

Musiquelle26: Killing innocents on large scale, i.e nukes, is wrong

Musiquelle26: tit for tat, so to speak.

ddavitt has entered the room.

geeairmoe2: Innocents don't harbor terrorists.

AGplusone: We

AGplusone: don't

AGplusone: nuke

AGplusone: them

ddavitt: Y'all still here? Don't you have homes to go to?:-)

Musiquelle26: Hey lady...I'm stirring up the hornets nest, I fear

AGplusone: We may invade their land ... and if they don't get out of the way that's too bad

AGplusone: but

AGplusone: We

AGplusone: don't

geeairmoe2: Like I said, give me an option that will leave a more indeliable impression.

AGplusone: nuke

AGplusone: them

AGplusone: I'm not looking for impressions

Musiquelle26: Occupation will work, but for how long?

ddavitt: Ah..well, I just put the girls to bed and thought I'd see if there was anyone here

DavidWrightSr: You are overlooking the fact that a terrorist or small group of

ddavitt: As I missed most of the chat earlier.

Musiquelle26: Does the next generation bomb my daughter's place of work to retaliate for that?

DavidWrightSr: terrorists don't *have* to have a country's support.

DJedPar: Gppd Night Jane

Musiquelle26: We're talking a culture that has centuries of tit-for-tat retribution on all sides

AGplusone: They don't give a damn about the people with whom they take refuge

AGplusone: I don't want to impress anyone. I just want to kill the ones who espouse terrorism. If I have to go in

AGplusone: the next week and do it again, then so be it.

AGplusone: But I'm willing to give the ones who do not espouse terrorism the right to live afterwards.

AGplusone: I recognize that most of those people at best are along for the ride.

Musiquelle26: Then we, as a country, must maintain the vigilance, and not slump back into ....

AGplusone: At worst, they're oppressed by the same bastards.

Musiquelle26: "damn the miltary, we don't need them anymore" attitude

DJedPar has left the room.

Musiquelle26: There was a strong apathy about the military before the Gulf War, then it became a good thin

Musiquelle26: When I got in, most Gulf War vets were gettng out, and the country didn't care about us

AGplusone: always the same story, Stephanie

AGplusone: most of the country doesn't care about anything except filling its rice bowl

AGplusone: just like China

Musiquelle26: What I'm saying so poorly, is I don't see, even IF we did nuke, that we can get rid of this

Musiquelle26: Perhaps, I'm too defeatist

geeairmoe2 has left the room.

AGplusone: We can't doing it that way. We get rid of them the same way we get rid of the Nazi ... deNazification

AGplusone: that requires occupation

AGplusone: Dave: I think we're about done. Did you catch the part to edit out. The references to Tawn and Filly

AGplusone: in MI MOSes?

Musiquelle26: I see that part of the point. What I fear is that the violence is inherant to the religious

DavidWrightSr: Got it

AGplusone: Okay.

AGplusone: I think it is.

AGplusone: That doesn't get solved in a generation.

AGplusone: Like the Crusades

AGplusone: the thing to do is to remove the folk that espouse it

AGplusone: Make that the deterent

AGplusone: Hang them all.

Musiquelle26: Alright. My thick skull just let in the point you were making :-)

AGplusone: And then watch the next generation, and the one after that, and the one after that, ad infinitum

Musiquelle26: I'm an idiot, but at least I admit it

AGplusone: 'a woman's work is never done' You have just entered room "Heinlein Readers Group chat."

AGplusone: Love to them all, Filly

Musiquelle26: And to all of your families

ddavitt: Night everyone.

Musiquelle26 has left the room.

AGplusone: wb, Dave. I think we got it out of our systems. Jane, what next?

DavidWrightSr: Got dropped. I was just about to close it out. Anything I missed?

ddavitt: Topics?

AGplusone: nothing missed. Topics?

AGplusone: Report on Con?

AGplusone: and what else

ddavitt: Con; though it seems like a million years ago

ddavitt: After that we need to firm up some guests

ddavitt: Connie, Mr Kondo, Lois Bujold, Crais...

AGplusone: ah, ...

ddavitt: All possibles

AGplusone: Okay, why don't we just start a schedule

AGplusone: First one to say yes, we go with

ddavitt: Racism chat would be a good one; we touched on that on Thursday

TAWN3 has entered the room.

ddavitt: Bill and Andy were supposed to do that I think

AGplusone: wb, fighting through the ether, Tawn

ddavitt: We can nudge them.

TAWN3: Hi!

AGplusone: talking about schedule

DavidWrightSr: Log officially closed at 8:04 P.M. EDT.

Final End Of Discussion Log

Click Here to Return to Index

Return To Index

  Join The Heinlein Society and Pay Forward the legacy of Robert A. Heinlein and Virginia Heinlein.

2001-2010 The Heinlein Society
3553 Atlantic Avenue, #341
Long Beach, CA 90807-5606


The Heinlein Society was founded by Virginia Heinlein on behalf of her husband, science fiction author Robert Anson Heinlein, to "pay forward" the legacy of Robert A. Heinlein to future generations of "Heinlein's Children."